Drop In and Slide In Ranges Compared

When remodeling your kitchen, one of the biggest decisions is what type of range to choose. Do you go for a classic drop-in range or a modern slide-in range? While both offer convenient cooking, there are some key differences to understand before deciding which is best for your space and needs.

In this comparison guide, we'll dive into the pros and cons of drop in versus slide in ranges. We'll look at how they differ in installation, design, features, performance, and cost. With an overview of the distinguishing factors, you'll be prepared to make the right choice for your kitchen.

Defining Drop In vs Slide In Ranges

First, let's clarify what exactly drop in and slide in refer to when it comes to kitchen ranges.

What is a drop in range?

A drop in range gets its name from the fact that it literally drops into a cutout space in the kitchen counter. The range requires custom cabinetry and countertops designed specifically to fit that model. The range drops in from the top and gets secured underneath. This provides a continuous counter level and flush-fit look once installed.

What is a slide in range?

Slide in ranges get their name because they slide in between kitchen cabinets instead of dropping in from above. The range simply slides into the space between two existing cabinets or into a slot of custom cabinetry. The sides are contoured to provide an integrated look by fitting snugly against the cabinets.

Key differences in installation

The main difference comes down to how they fit into the kitchen design:

• Drop in ranges require customized cabinetry and countertops to specifically fit the appliance.
• Slide in ranges slide between existing cabinets and don't require as much customization.

This impacts the effort and cost of installing each style. Drop in ranges often require contracting professionals to cut precise openings. Slide in ranges don't require major construction, and many homeowners install them on their own.

Impact on kitchen design and layout

Because drop in ranges need specially made countertops, the design is more fixed. Cabinetry and counters must be built around the range's dimensions. Slide in ranges offer more flexibility for remodeling. You don't have to completely customize cabinetry. Just make sure there is a 30-36 inch wide opening, depending on the range size.

For kitchen layout, drop ins allow more flexibility. Since they don't need to slide between cabinets, they can go anywhere that works with the countertop design. Slide ins can only fit where there's an appropriate gap between cabinets.

Drop In Range Benefits and Drawbacks

What are the upsides and downsides of installing a drop in range versus a slide in?

Pros of drop in ranges

• Seamless built-in look: When installed properly, drop in ranges appear like one continuous surface with the counters.
• Easy to clean around: With flat countertops around the range, crumb and spill clean up is simpler.
• Wide variety of sizes: Drop in ranges come in widths from 20-48 inches to fit different kitchen plans.

Cons of drop in ranges

• Require expert installation: The customized construction often requires hiring contractors and carpenters.
• Not as versatile for kitchen remodels: The permanent cabinetry makes replacements and changes harder down the road.

Slide In Range Benefits and Drawbacks

Pros of slide in ranges

• Easier DIY installation: Slide in ranges don't require major construction modifications, making DIY installation more feasible.
• Fit more kitchen layouts: Just a 30-36 inch gap is needed, allowing more flexibility.
• Can replace without cabinet work: To upgrade in the future, slide in ranges can swap out without rebuilding cabinets.

Cons of slide in ranges

• Visible gaps around edges: There can be slight gaps between the range and cabinets.
• Less selection of sizes: Typically come in 30-36 inch widths to fit cabinet cutouts.
• Not as flush with counters: They sit on top of cabinets instead of dropping in evenly.

Compare Cooking Performance

Beyond just installation and design, performance is crucial when choosing appliances. How do drop in and slide in ranges compare when it comes to cooking features?

Heating types by range style

Both range styles are available with gas, electric, and induction cooktops. There are some differences though:

• Electric drop ins often have smoothtop surfaces without grates.
• Gas slide in ranges may have open burners or a continuous grate surface.

Oven capacity considerations

Slide in ovens tend to have slightly lower capacity since they can only be as deep as the base cabinets. Standard ovens are around 5 cubic feet. Drop in ovens housed in deeper cabinetry provide larger capacity around 6 cubic feet.

Cooktop setup and burner options

Drop in ranges sometimes come with bigger cooktops - up to 6 burners. Slide ins max out at 5 burners. Drop ins can also have unique cooktop shapes and burner arrangements tailored to the cutout space.

Both range types now offer high powered burners up to 20,000 BTU. Specialty burners like oval fish fryers are also available.

Extra features like convection or induction

You'll find similar extra features between the styles like convection fans for faster, more even baking. Some pro-style models have options like induction cooktops or steam ovens.

Cost Differences Between Styles

Price is often a major factor when choosing new kitchen appliances. What's the typical budget for each range style?

Drop in range pricing factors

For drop in ranges, the installation is a big part of the total cost. The range itself ranges from $1000-3000 depending on features and fuel type. Custom cabinetry can add $2000-5000 to have everything cut to fit. Overall, the total investment ranges from $3000 on the low end to $8000 on the high end.

Typical slide in range costs

For slide in models, you avoid some of the installation costs. The ranges themselves run from $800 to $2500. Some choose to do their own basic install. But hiring an appliance installer or contractor typically costs $200-500. Overall investment for slide in ranges spans $1000 to $3000.

Budgeting for professional installation

To have the process completely handled by kitchen professionals, estimate:

• Drop in range install: $2000-$5000
• Slide in range install: $500-$1500

Cost per cubic foot of capacity

Because drop ins often have larger oven capacity, they can provide a lower cost per cubic foot. However, slide in ranges offer big enough ovens for most households.

Choosing What's Right for Your Kitchen

With all of the comparisons and factors covered, how do you decide whether a drop in or slide in range is the right choice?

Consider the size of your kitchen and placement limitations. If space is tight, a slide in style likely makes more sense. Drop ins need ample room for the accompanying cabinetry. But if you have an open concept kitchen, a drop in range can anchor your cooking zone.